Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Menu (Update 2026)

Mikey's Pizzeria in Whittemore makes each meal a celebration of flavor. The menu features classic options like the beloved BLT Pizza and a range of cheesy delights. With 12 varieties of pizza, there's something for everyone, whether you prefer a single topping or a loaded slice with a multitude of ingredients. Special orders include deals like 2 small 12" pizzas or 2 large 16" pizzas that ensure everyone's cravings are satisfied during game nights or family dinners. Don't miss the garlic sticks and deep-fried mushrooms, perfect companions for any order. Sweeten the end of your meal with their flavorful cinnamon sticks, a local favorite. With a total of 42 items on the menu, variety surely thrives here.

Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Menu image 1
Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Menu image 2
Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Menu image 3
Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Breadsticks
Breadsticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Meat Lovers
Meat Lovers
Hawaiian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore

Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Interior, Food, Ambiance

The ambiance at Mikey's Pizzeria brings a cozy charm that reflects the warmth of the Whittemore community. With inviting seating arrangements, it feels welcoming for both families and friends gathering over a meal or individuals stopping by to grab a slice. The interior is casual yet vibrant, adorned with local memorabilia, which adds a touch of homey ambiance.

Patrons enjoy the aroma of freshly baked pizzas wafting through the air as they wait for their orders, setting the stage for a satisfying dining experience. There's an energy here, filled with laughter and chatter, making it easy to lose track of time while enjoying a hearty meal. For those who prefer take-out, the hustle in the kitchen assures quick and delightful service.

Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore

About Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore Food and Specialties

Mikey's Pizzeria stands out in the Whittemore area with its commitment to hearty portions and bold flavors. The standout item is undoubtedly the BLT Pizza, which offers a unique twist for those looking to branch out from traditional toppings. The pizzas are generously piled with toppings, ensuring that every bite is packed with flavor.

Strombolis and pizza pockets have a loyal following, delighting locals with their robust fillings and zesty sauces. Add in a selection of subs ranging from ham to roast beef, and you'll find familiar flavors that comfort as much as they satisfy.

For those indulging in deep-fried favorites, the fried mushrooms and golden onion rings bring a delicious crunch that pairs beautifully with pizzas.

Mikey's Pizzeria Whittemore

Mikey's Pizzeria prides itself on its commitment to quality and community. The team focuses on sourcing fresh ingredients from local suppliers, ensuring that every dish supports both the local economy and provides diners with the best flavors. The specialty here revolves around serving pizzas that cater to every palate, showcasing creativity alongside tradition in their menu offerings.

With a vision centered around fostering community connections, Mikey's aims to be more than just a dining spot. It strives to serve as a gathering place, bringing locals and visitors together over shared meals.

Special events and promotions often highlight local activities, reinforcing its role as a central part of Whittemore’s social fabric. Whether it's a casual dinner with friends or a celebration surrounded by family, Mikey’s is committed to making every experience memorable.